Why Animals Are Sometimes the Wrong Color

Animals are one of the first things we learn about as kids. We learn that cows moo, lions roar and frogs ribbit. We learn about farm animals and wild animals from storybooks and songs. As our knowledge grows, we learn how to identify animals by their appearance.

This is a red fox with black fur, a normal variation from the more common red color. (Photo courtesy of Mark Hanna)

One of the first things we consider when identifying an animal is its color. We know deer are brown and skunks are black with a white stripe. We know birds come in many colors and sizes. Those different colors and sizes are what help us tell a robin from a sparrow.


But sometimes animals are the wrong color. In some cases, this is easily explained. Some animals, particularly those in the arctic, change color in the winter to match the snowy landscape. And some animals, like the chameleon, are famous for their color-changing ability. Other times, though, a wrong-colored animal seems hard to explain.


Learn more about why animals sometimes look much different than we expect — or sometimes aren’t what they seem at all.


Normal color variation


In some cases, an animal may not be the color you expect it to be simply because multiple colors are possible. One such example is the red fox. While most red foxes are the rusty red color we are familiar with, not all are. Some red foxes are the usual reddish-brown but with a black stripe down their backs and another across their shoulders. Others can be silvery or nearly black in color.


Similarly, coyotes are not always the color we expect. Most are grayish-brown, but their fur can range from a blonde-like color to a reddish-brown to a dark gray or almost black color. When coyotes are a different color than their usual grayish-brown, they are often confused with other animals, like wolves or even dogs.


For some animals, especially birds, it’s normal for males and females to be entirely different colors. Take two of our most brightly colored birds, indigo buntings and northern cardinals. Male buntings are a bright blue, while male cardinals are an eye-catching red. The females are more drab, though. Female indigo buntings are brown. And female cardinals are mostly buff colored with just a few red highlights. Many ducks also have much more colorfully feathered males than females.


Albinism and leucism


In many cases, when an animal is not the color it should be, it is white or partially white instead. This can result from one of two conditions caused by genetic mutations: albinism or leucism.

A robin with leucism. (Photo via Shutterstock)

Albinism is caused by a genetic mutation that disrupts that animal’s ability to produce melanin, the pigment that gives many animals their color. Animals, including humans, with albinism inherit the gene from both parents, although the parents themselves may not have albinism.


Leucism also has to do with melanin production, but these animals still produce melanin. The problem is in how the melanin is distributed in the animals’ fur, feathers and skin. In some areas, the melanin is distributed normally, while in other spots it is absent. Leucism can result in just a few white patches or an almost entirely white appearance. Animals that are partially white as a result of leucism are sometimes called piebald.


How can you tell if an animal is white because of albinism or leucism? The easiest way is to check its eyes. Animals (and people) with albinism will have pink or reddish eyes because the lack of pigment makes the color of the blood vessels in the eye visible. Portions of their skin not covered by fur or feathers will also be light colored or pale colored.


Both leucism and albinism are rare in animals, although albinism is much more rare. Albinism occurs in between 1 in 20,000 and 1 in 1 million animals, depending on the species. It is thought to be more common in amphibians, reptiles and birds.


Animals with leucism and albinism can be more vulnerable than other animals because of how these conditions affect their camouflage and social structure, as well as placing them at increased risk of poaching. When they are found in the wild, they are often taken to animal sanctuaries and zoos so they can be protected.


Genetic mutations


Albinism and leucism aren’t the only genetic mutations that can cause an animal to stand out for its unusual coloring. It happens in many other ways as well, resulting in other seemingly miscolored animals.

A cardinal with yellow feathers is extremely rare. (Photo via Shutterstock)

One example many people are familiar with is black squirrels. These squirrels aren’t a separate species from the eastern gray squirrels and fox squirrels most of us are familiar with. Instead, they are gray squirrels and fox squirrels with a genetic mutation called melanism that causes their fur to be black instead of the usual color. In the case of black squirrels, the genetic mutation causes their fur to be darker because of excess melanin.


Other animals can experience melanism as well. In fact, the black panther is the melanistic expression of a jaguar, although it was once thought to be a separate species. Other wildcats can also be all black because of melanism.


Black squirrels are common enough that they don’t generate headlines, but sometimes it’s quite the story when an animal turns up looking anything but normal. For example, we know male cardinals are red and females are a buff color, but every once in a while a yellow cardinal is spotted in the wild, and it’s a real showstopper. Such was the case in 2021 when a yellow cardinal was spotted in Rushville, Illinois. Similarly, yellow cardinals seen in Alabama in 2018 and in Florida in 2019 generated a lot of attention.


Yellow cardinals are a one in a million phenomenon — and probably even more rare than that. The unusual coloration is the result of a genetic mutation that blocks yellow pigments consumed by the birds from being converted to red pigments, which normally give the birds their color. Instead, those pigments, called carotenoids, are expressed as yellow.

Only about three yellow cardinal sightings are reported each year, and while cardinals are the most well-known example, it can occur in any red-colored bird.


Mistaken ID


Sometimes an animal is not the color you expect it to be because you aren’t seeing the animal you think you are. Many animals have lookalikes, and sometimes it’s more a case of mistaken identification than an animal being the wrong color.

 

Words to know

Albinism: An absence of pigment in the skin, hair, eyes, fur or feathers.

Carotenoid: A group of pigments that are yellow, orange and red.

Genetic: Relating to genes or heredity.

Leucism: An abnormal condition of reduced pigmentation.

Melanin: A group of natural pigments found in most living things.

Melanism: Unusual coloration caused by excessive melanin production.

Mutation: A change in the structure of a gene resulting in a variant form.

Pigment or pigmentation: The color of a living thing’s skin, hair, eyes, fur or feathers.

 

One such example would be foxes. Many people are familiar with red foxes, but gray foxes — another species altogether — have a range that overlaps with red foxes in many places. The two foxes live in many of the same types of habitat and have many of the same behaviors and look quite similar. Adding to the confusion is that red foxes can sometimes have gray fur or gray patches and gray foxes can sometimes have red fur or red patches. The easiest way to tell the difference between a red fox and a gray fox is to look at the tips of their tails. A red fox will have white fur at the tip of its tail, while a gray fox will have a black tail tip.


This can also be true of many bird species. The green heron, for example, has a similar body shape and habitat to the black-crowned night heron, least bittern and little blue heron, which can create some difficulty in identifying which bird you are seeing. In these cases, it’s helpful to know some of the distinguishing features between them so you will be able to tell the difference.

____________


Follow Willy's Wilderness on Facebook for more kid-friendly nature stories and activities.